Holly Jackson’s ‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’ is a whodunnit investigation by 17-year-old Pippa. I was initially skeptical because it is YA fiction, but did read it anyway, as it came recommended by a friend. I am glad I did because it was unputdownable.
Andie Bell was murdered five years ago. The main accused was her boyfriend, Salil Singh, who died before the investigation concluded. Pip revisits the cold case for a school project and uncovers things that don’t add up. She works with Sal’s brother, Ravi Singh, who wants to clear Sal’s name despite the evidence saying otherwise.
The plot is fast-paced, with twists and turns. There are clues strewn all over that tie up nicely. The book also addresses racism and how it affects an investigation and its aftermath. The book has a contemporary feel – a modern-day, social-media-active, ‘woke‘ Nancy Drew.
What didn’t work for me was the way Pip goes about her investigation. She tackles suspects head-on, and walks away unscathed, making it all too convenient. The interviewees seem gullible and ready to impart information at the drop of a hat. Even a notorious dealer seems very tame and threatened by Pip’s attempt to blackmail him.
Some subplots are too simple to be believable, but the characters and their interactions are well-etched and sustain your interest. I kind of guessed who the murderer was in the end, but it didn’t take away the joy of the mystery. Despite its flaws, this book is worth a read. Further, it has been adapted on screen and is streaming on Netflix.
The copy I picked up from the library is a hardbound collector’s edition and is gorgeous!! I loved the zig-zag lines on the side and the shiny front cover. Overall, I found this to be an enjoyable and intriguing read.
I liked this review as well!